If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.
Film & TV

Fan Favorite Theories from WandaVision That Didn’t Pan Out

So much potential. This article contains spoilers.

Warning: this article contains heavy spoilers for WandaVision and Avengers: Endgame.

If you haven't seen every episode of WandaVision yet, bookmark this article, go watch it, and come back. I'll wait…

Still waiting…

Ok, you binged it in all its glory? Great. Wasn't it fantastic?!

As you probably realized, the Disney+ original takes place after the events of Avengers: Endgame in the Marvel Cinematic Universe canon. The show opens and closes Wanda’s story of grief after losing Vision and officially sets her up as the Scarlet Witch, heavily inspired by the comics.

Each episode of WandaVision lovingly recreates an episode from a popular sitcom in different decades – from I Love Lucy to Modern Family. Through the genius of Darcy Lewis, played by Kat Dennings, the folks at S.W.O.R.D. are able to “see” into each episode, and decipher it to figure out what is really happening in Wanda’s world, the Hex.

WandaVision stands out as a show with so much potential. It’s been the first taste of an MCU film or show that we’ve had in a long while, and it’s positioning after Endgame should help us transition between that movie and the next. After each episode, fans dissected the show for easter eggs and clues that might point towards the show’s big bad, or the man behind the curtain.

At this point, we can safely say that almost all of those fan theories didn’t pan out. Despite the numerous clues pointing towards other villains from the Marvel comics, mentions of Avengers by name, and cameos with mystery characters. All of that turned out to be a misdirect, smoke and mirrors… an illusion.


Here are the best fan theories that we didn’t see in WandaVision.

Mephisto as the Big Bad

The clues for Mephisto as the villain in WandaVision started very early. There were so many clues, in fact, I recommend you just watch the video above to see them all. Suffice to say, almost every episode had references to Mephisto. My personal theory was that S.W.O.R.D. Director Hayward was Mephisto in disguise, because in episode eight, he clearly was leading Wanda to steal Vision’s body.

Agatha Harkness’ last words: “You don’t know what you’ve done,” could hint towards a threat that she knows of, but Wanda does not—which could be Mephisto—but chances are we won’t find out for a while.


Although Nightmare will likely be the villain in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, there was still the potential that he would be teased or referenced in WandaVision. Obviously, that didn’t work out.

Doctor Strange Cameo


We know that Elizabeth Olsen will reprise her role as Wanda Maximoff in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Since it's MCU fan common knowledge, a Benedict Cumberbatch cameo wasn’t out of the question. He’s even mentioned by title, the Sorcerer Supreme, by Agatha Harkness, as someone whose power Wanda has surpassed as the Scarlet Witch.

Unfortunately, everybody’s favorite name jumbling British actor was a no-show in WandaVision, so we’ll have to wait til Multiverse of Madness to see them share the screen.

Reed Richards

One of the more far out cameo theories was Reed Richards, the leader of the Fantastic Four. One of the smartest characters in the comics who had his hands in every piece of reality bending science imaginable, he had a lot of potential to be involved in a multiverse storyline. 

Unfortunately, we did not see him, and I’m not sure we will for some time, although we will see Marvel’s First Family in the MCU, as confirmed by Kevin Feige at Disney’s Investor Day in December 2020.

Pietro / Fietro*

The moment Evan Peters appeared onscreen, a complicated web of storylines started to converge in my mind. This was one of many steps Disney would take to bridge the gap between the MCU and the X-Men movies. By casting Evan Peters’ X-Men Quicksilver as Aaron Taylor-Johnson’s MCU Quicksilver, it would open the possibility of a crossover and future integration of the two separate universes, possibly fueled by Wanda’s reality-warping powers.


It made a lot of sense.

It was also complete garbage, apparently.

Fietro turned out to be a creation of Agatha Harkness, and was later identified as Ralph Bohner, and with that, the complex house of cards that had assembled itself in my head between episodes five and six of WandaVision collapsed.

The “Big” Cameo

Although Tom Holland is well known for spoiling names of things, that isn’t the case with every actor in the MCU. Paul Bettany played into this in an interview, stating that there was a cameo coming later in the season, where he was able to work alongside an actor that he had been excited to work with. The cameo? Paul Bettany, as White Vision. 

He’s a professional actor. He was acting, and he trolled every single one of us.

The Darkhold

One of the most used powerful macguffins in Marvel film and TV is the Darkhold. Every time I see it, it has the potential to expand the show I am currently watching with other shows – fans of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and Runaways will know what I’m talking about.

Every time I see it, it fails to make the obvious connection. It looks like Marvel’s other adventures on television will never be a part of the MCU canon.

However, this may be the first Darkhold to be referenced in more than one movie or show—and part of the MCU canon—as fans are guessing that it is one of the missing books from Kamar-Taj, the temple where Stephen Strange learned magic.

In the end, WandaVision was a mostly self-contained story, serving its purpose to slightly bridge the gap between Phase 3 and 4 of the MCU. It introduced magic in a more formal way with witches, covens, and the Darkhold, and we now officially have the Scarlet Witch, and a hint as to her intentions in the next movie.

All episodes of WandaVision are streaming on Disney+, as of Friday, March 5, 2021. I would encourage you not to read into the mid- and post-credits scenes. Given how little the show delved into the greater world, those scenes might be misdirects as well. Unless…

Official merch

Film & TV articles

  • Image for NYCC 2021 | Star Trek: Prodigy Premiere Screening & Panel

    NYCC 2021 | Star Trek: Prodigy Premiere Screening & Panel

    Join Paramount+, CBS Studios, and Nickelodeon for a premiere screening for the whole family of the highly anticipated upcoming “Star Trek” animated kids’ series, STAR TREK: PRODIGY. Following the screening, voice cast members Kate Mulgrew, Brett Gray, Rylee Alazraqui and Dee Bradley Baker, producers Kevin Hageman, Dan Hageman, and Ben Hibon, and Ramsey Naito, President, Animation & Development, Paramount Animation, and Nickelodeon Animation, will take the stage for a moderated panel discussion.

    Film & TV
  • Image for NYCC 2021 | Salute to Supernatural - A Retrospective on 15 Years of Saving People, Hunting Things, and the Family Business
    Premium access

    NYCC 2021 | Salute to Supernatural - A Retrospective on 15 Years of Saving People, Hunting Things, and the Family Business

    In 15 years Supernatural went from a cult WB show to holding the record for the longest running American sci-fi/fantasy TV program. 2020 may have marked the end of the Winchesters story, but the fans continue to celebrate the legacy the show left behind. So gas up the 1967 Chevy Impala for one last ride as we dissect the series finale, dive into 327 episodes worth of Sam and Dean shenanigans, and discuss the cultural - and personal - impact of this hit CW program.

    Film & TV
  • Image for NYCC 2021 | What We Do in the Shadows (FX) Season 3 Takes NYCC!

    NYCC 2021 | What We Do in the Shadows (FX) Season 3 Takes NYCC!

    FX’s Emmy®-nominated vampire comedy What We Do in the Shadows returns to New York Comic Con for a LIVE discussion with members of the cast and creative team. Catch a special presentation of an upcoming episode and join special guests in a lively conversation about the series Rolling Stone named “the funniest show on television.” What We Do in the Shadows is a documentary-style look into the daily (or rather, nightly) lives of four vampires who’ve “lived” together for hundreds of years. Seasons 3 currently airs Thursdays at 10pm ET/PT on FX and streams the next day on FX on Hulu. Don’t miss the chance to attend the Vampiric Council of the Eastern Seaboard of the New World’s first public meeting! BAT!

    Film & TV
  • Image for NYCC 2021 | Broadway's A.J. Holmes: Creating One-Man Musical Yeah, But Not Right Now
    Premium access

    NYCC 2021 | Broadway's A.J. Holmes: Creating One-Man Musical Yeah, But Not Right Now

    Join Broadway star A.J. Holmes (Book of Mormon, StarKid Productions) in discussion with director Caitlin Cook (Edinburgh Fringe, HBO's WICF) and sound designer Craig Bundy (Subculture) about bringing his new one-man musical Yeah, But Not Right Now (currently running at the Soho Playhouse through October 16th) to the stage. Holmes will play some pieces from the show and open the door for questions about creating a cohesive hour of comedy, music, and theater; writing musical comedy; and what it's like to be a bargain bin Bo Burnham.

    Film & TV

Latest articles

  • Image for NYCC 2021 | Cospositivity: Fitness & Body Love in the Cosplay Community
    Premium access

    NYCC 2021 | Cospositivity: Fitness & Body Love in the Cosplay Community

    Hosted by Heather Boddy. The cosplay community should be a safe space for people of all shapes and sizes. Unfortunately that is not always the case. Of course we want to feel amazing strong and empowered in our cosplays but that doesn’t mean we have to beat ourselves up at the gym to look like the character we are cosplaying. In this panel we will discuss how to fall in love with fitness and channel your inner superhero as well as what it means to love yourself throughout the process. Cosplay and fitness should both feel empowering. Let’s have a conversation about how to feel better in our bodies in and out of cosplay.

  • Image for NYCC 2021 | What a Drag! A Panel on drag and cosplay!
    Premium access

    NYCC 2021 | What a Drag! A Panel on drag and cosplay!

    From Video Games to Comics Anime and more come explore a world where Drag meets Cosplay! This inclusive panel of queens kings and everything in between will be having an open discussion about cosplaying their favorite characters through the queer lens as well as challenges we face melding the two artforms together within the industry of drag.
 We'll touch on a range of topics including our favorite cosplays how we create our performances and creating art that honors source materials while also being culturally responsible and avoiding cultural appropriation. We believe that drag and cosplay are for everyone and that there is so much both communities can teach each other about their respective art forms in order to help everyone grow as transformation artists. So come with your questions (even those filled with tea or shade!) and let’s talk about nerdy drag! Moderated by Crimson Kitty (Mx. Nerd NY 2018) and special guest Erika Klash

  • Image for NYCC 2021 | SHEPROP! HAS YOUR BACK: Supporting women trans and non-binary cosplayers in a creative world
    Premium access

    NYCC 2021 | SHEPROP! HAS YOUR BACK: Supporting women trans and non-binary cosplayers in a creative world

    Women, trans, and nonbinary cosplayers can face unique challenges when looking for help. Body shaming self-esteem ability shaming slut-shaming and misogyny can be barriers to getting the help and support we need. The SheProp! Community is here to help including Raisin Cosplay, Maweezy, Tin Lizzy, ThouArtAnuli, SewSilly, and Rebecca Noel. Our panelists of experienced cosplayers are ready to answer your questions whether they are about creating a costume or surviving and thriving in the cosplay community. Come and join the discussion about why SheProp! has quickly become a vital presence for women trans and non-binary makers providing a space for accessible support & encouragement for costume designers SFX artists cosplayers and more at all skill levels.

  • Image for NYCC 2021 | Nailed It: Project Cosplay!
    Premium access

    NYCC 2021 | Nailed It: Project Cosplay!

    Nailed It: Project Cosplay is back again after a highly successful run in 2018 to bring you an hour of fun and creative competition! Think you have what it takes to cobble together a standout cosplay in an hour? Compete with your friends and family to create the cosplay of your dreams with unexpected items! But don't worry our judges (fashion industry designers & cosplayers) will be there to coach you & cheer you on! So gather your squad & come to show off your skills. Trust us this will be the most fun you have at NYCC!